Hello dear
Welcome To Kate & Al's Pizza
Kate & Al's Pizza is a hidden gem located at 2919 US-206 #104 in Columbus, NJ. Despite its unassuming appearance, the pizza here is exceptional. The menu offers a variety of options, from traditional pies to unique creations like the Breakfast Pizza. Customers rave about the flavorful sauce, airy crust, and generous toppings. The Sicilian slices are a fan favorite, with a fluffy texture and rich flavor that will leave you wanting more. While the prices may be slightly higher, the quality and taste of the pizza make it worth every penny. Don't miss out on this local favorite for a delicious pizza experience.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Works Pizza
Whole Breakfast Pizza
Whole Broccoli Pizza
Whole plain pizza
About
Kate & Al's Pizza
If you're a pizza enthusiast looking for a hidden gem in Columbus, look no further than Kate & Al's Pizza. This unassuming pizza joint may not have a modern appearance, but what it lacks in aesthetics, it more than makes up for in flavor and quality. This family-owned establishment offers a variety of mouthwatering pizzas, including Sicilian slices that are consistently ranked as number one by customers.
One of the standout features of Kate & Al's Pizza is their thick, flavorful sauce that can stand on its own. The tomato pie with chunky sauce and a generous sprinkling of cheese is a unique twist on traditional pizza offerings. The crust, while thick and hearty, remains light and airy with a nice yeasty flavor that complements the toppings perfectly.
Customers rave about the secret sauce used at Kate & Al's, describing it as a burst of flavor like no other. The Sicilian pizza's fluffy texture and rich taste leave patrons in awe, making each bite a delightful experience. Despite occasional wait times, the quality of the food is well worth the patience, and there are plenty of activities to do in the area while you await your order.
In addition to their standout pizzas, Kate & Al's also offers a range of beverages to pair with your meal, including red cream soda that perfectly complements the flavors of their pies. Whether you're a local looking for your new favorite pizza spot or a traveler planning their vacation around a visit to Kate & Al's, this pizza joint is sure to please even the pickiest of pizza lovers. Don't miss out on this delicious and unique dining experience that has customers coming back time and time again.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ So I won't lie the location of the pizza place didn't give me the most hope because it's most definitely not a modern appearance... but don't let that sway you... the pizza was phenomenal...it's also CASH only so be prepared for that! The prices seemed a bit on the high end... we paid $34 for a large pizza... but yanno ... inflation... We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, bacon and sausage! It was perfectly cooked, hot, and honestly mouth watering . I have to address that they had accidentally made an extra order and they offered 2 extra pizzas to us so that they wouldn't go to waste! We were able to feed two extra families in our neighborhood which I thought was amazing! I love that they asked if they would go to a good use instead of the trash! Overall.... This place lives us to the hype!!! I will be a repeat customer! ”
“ As usual their pizza is #1 Sicilian slices. Their service is the best it gets with so many call in orders you still get your slices promptly. It's the Columbus Sale with past renovation from past fire. There are a few tables of 4 seats. ”
“ This is now on my regular rotation when I'm in the mood for thicker crust. The sauce is flavorful and can stand on its own. It's a thick layer but the crust holds up to it. It's not your typical pizza but more of a tomato pie with chunky sauce. Little bit of cheese. The crust isn't as thick as Sicilian and very light and airy. Has a nice yeasty flavor. You have to call well in advance because the wait is usually an hour. Don't forget it's cash only!! ”
“ we love Kate & Al's. Pizza is Great. Better than Pete's IMO. I have heard the Breakfast pizza is good but haven't gotten there in time to get some. ”
“ Straight forward take out, one style , square , deep , solid sauce , lightly sprinkled cheese. Almost the same as Pete's across the parking lot, slightly sweeter sauce. Both are delicious and old school. Take 2 home now Or 1 from both and compare. Not to be missed by pizza freaks. ”
